Broken window mechanism

[peltolivier]

Hi everybody, my right window mechanism doesn't work anymore so I removed it. When I tried to look for a new part I see that there is MANUAL WINDOW REGULATOR 8229769 on ebay from DG Rally. But I also found another one which looks like a face lifted (better) one (see other attachment). Is the 'newer' one better or should I get the original one?

[peteracs]

Hi

It may be simpler to repair your old one, they are pretty simple. Depending on what you find it will most likely either be a worn out cog or the drive coil.

Peter